> Cigars > My Father

Share >>

My Father The Judge

Justin says:

"Great stick!"

My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5 5/8 * 46

Christopher says:

"A smooth spice bomb, with sweet caramel undertones. Hits above $$"

James says:

"Thursday smoke"

Jimmie says:

"My Father for the win!!"

Jeffrey says:

"Perfect cigar for an unusually cool August evening in Ohio. "

Matt says:

"Amazing construction, but not overly blown away by it. Have had plenty better NC's"

Frantz says:

"Weekend vibe. Amazing draw, smooth and flavorful."

Chris says:

"Cigar Aficionado cigar of the year 2024 for a reason. Great holiday smoke as well!"

Ted says:

"Fantastic Cigar. My Father "The Judge""

Kyle says:

"Best size for The Judge!"

My Father The Judge is an extension of the celebrated My Father brand featuring richer, more full bodied tobaccos than the original line. The added strength comes from the addition of Corojo binder and an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper.

Cigar Origin
Nicaragua
Most cigars are manufactured in the Caribbean and Central America.
Despite many decades of war and revolution in this Central American country, the cigar industry has thrived due to the hard work and tenacity of Cuban exiles to the land such as Plasencia, Padron, Oliva, Ortez, and others. Tobacco has been a force of social stability, and the country is now one of the principal exporters of premium cigars in the world.
Strength

Full
Wrapper Color
Colorado Maduro
Cigar wrapper color varies from green (Double Claro or Candela) to black (Maduro or Oscuro) with a full range of browns in between.
Colorado maduro wrapper is milk chocolate brown.
Wrapper
Ecuadorian Sumatra-Seed
The wrapper is the last tobacco leaf to be rolled on the cigar, so it is the one the smoker will see.
Ecuador is the perfect place to grow wrappers, because it is located on the Equator! And it has rich soils too. The weather conditions, with a nearly permanent cloudy sky, provide a natural shade, protecting the wrapper plants from sunshine and allowing the tobacco to grow thin and light. Ecuador supplies Connecticut and Sumatra type wrappers to many cigar factory in the world.
Binder
Nicaragua
The binder is a full tobacco leaf that is used to roll the cigar, binding the filler tobaccos together.
Nicaraguan cigar binders are produced mainly in Esteli and Jalapa, both lands with volcanic soil and excellent climate for growing tobacco. Binders grown in Jalapa have sweet undertones. Corojo, Habana2000, Criollo, and Maduro binders are all produced in Nicaragua.
Filler
Nicaragua
Filler is the term used to describe the tobacco inside a cigar or the "guts" of the cigar.
Rolled by
Handmade
Handmade cigars are completely made by hand from start to finish.
Manufacturer
My Father Cigars
My Father Cigars manufactures handmade premium cigars in Miami and Esteli, Nicaragua. The company is owned and operated by Don Pepin, his son Jaime, and his daughter Janny. The "Garcia Family Industrial Park" located in Esteli, Nicaragua is a seven-acre complex with 9 buildings, over 1900 employees, where the Garcias supervise their cigar production from the tobacco field to the roller's table. Their Miami headquarters house 12 rollers that make all of the company's "handmade in Miami" brands.

My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

(58)

Corona Extra, Full, Colorado Maduro, from Nicaragua

	MSRP	OUR PRICE	YOU SAVE	SMOKE RINGS	AVAILABILITY	QUANTITY
Box of 20	$232.00	$208.95 FREE SHIPPING	$23.05	1040	Backorder Ships 06/08 - 06/10
Single	$11.60	$11.05	$0.55	55	In Stock Ships Tomorrow

My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

(155)

Robusto, Full, Colorado Maduro, from Nicaragua

	MSRP	OUR PRICE	YOU SAVE	SMOKE RINGS	AVAILABILITY	QUANTITY
Box of 20	$266.00	$239.40 FREE SHIPPING	$26.60	1195	Backorder
Single	$13.30	$13.30		65	Backorder

My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

(155)

Toro, Full, Colorado Maduro, from Nicaragua

	MSRP	OUR PRICE	YOU SAVE	SMOKE RINGS	AVAILABILITY	QUANTITY
Box of 20	$260.00	$233.95 FREE SHIPPING	$26.05	1165	In Stock Ships Tomorrow
Single	$13.00	$12.35	$0.65	60	In Stock Ships Tomorrow

My Father Limited Edition Father's Day 8-Cigar Sampler with Accessories

The My Father Cigars Father’s Day 8 Cigar Sampler is built to impress, combining four of the brand’s most celebrated blends with high-quality accessories in one limited-edition package. Inside are two cigars of each from the acclaimed Le Bijou 1922, The Judge, La Opulencia, and Flor de las Antillas lines—offering a wide range of the best the legendary García family has to offer. Produced by My Father Cigars in Nicaragua, each blend in this collection showcases the company’s signature combination of bold flavor, flawless construction, and award-winning consistency. Beyond the cigars, the sampler also includes a melamine ashtray, cutter, and lighter, making it an exceptional all-in-one gift set for Father’s Day or any special occasion. Packed with premium extras and eight top-tier cigars for under $100, this exclusive sampler delivers serious value and a gift any dad will love.

	MSRP	OUR PRICE	YOU SAVE	SMOKE RINGS	AVAILABILITY	QUANTITY
	$100.00	$90.00	$10.00	450	In Stock Ships Tomorrow

Questions & Answers

(optional)

Ask

Thomas Daniel Hi, what's the total weight + dimensions of a box of 23? Thanks.

Posted 5/7/2025

NeptuneCigar.com This box measures about 8" x 7" x 3" and weighs approximately 2.6 pounds

Replied 5/7/2025

(optional)
Reply

Mats Hi from norway here, can it be shipt to norway and get past the toll

Posted 10/2/2024

NeptuneCigar.com I'm afraid we are unable to service the requested destination. Check out our international shipping policy to see a list of destinations we currently send to: https://www.neptunecigar.com/tips/international-shipping-policy---terms-and-conditions

Replied 10/2/2024

Anthony Hartmann Past the troll more like it.

Replied 5/24/2025

(optional)
Reply

James Cannon Hi what is the weight of one cigar . Thanks james

Posted 8/16/2024

NeptuneCigar.com This cigar weighs approximately 22g per stick.

Replied 8/16/2024

Vincenzo Caruso any idea if you will be restocking?

Replied 6/2/2026

(optional)
Reply

Ayden Robertson What is the weight of tobacco each stick. Thank you

Posted 3/18/2024

NeptuneCigar.com 21 grams

Replied 3/19/2024

(optional)
Reply

Greger Jean-louis II Can I get points for grading this cigar if I didn’t buy it there

Posted 2/13/2024

NeptuneCigar.com You must purchase the cigar from us to be able to leave a review for it.

Replied 2/14/2024

(optional)
Reply

Wally Grossi I've got a condo in Lauderdale and being a Canadian I'm not able to get down there. Do you ship to Canada?

Posted 7/16/2020

NeptuneCigar.com Not typically. Call us at 1-800-655-3385 to inquire further.

Replied 7/17/2020

(optional)
Reply

Bob Allison Are my father the judge available with smoke rings?

Posted 4/20/2020

NeptuneCigar.com You can redeem anything on our site(excluding single cigars) with smoke rings, so long as you have enough on your account. To start redeeming the Judge, you need a minimum 22,695 for the box of Corona Gorda.

Replied 4/21/2020

(optional)
Reply

ALSO FROM MY FATHER

My FatherDon Pepin Vegas CubanasMy Father Le Bijou 1922Jaime Garcia Reserva EspecialMy Father Limited EditionFlor de las AntillasLa AntiguedadMy Father ConnecticutDon Pepin Garcia JJMy Father El Centurion

ALSO FROM MY FATHER CIGARS

Nestor Miranda Special Selection RosadoLa Aroma de CubaLa Aroma de Cuba Edicion EspecialSan CristobalDon Pepin Garcia Blue EditionDon Pepin Garcia Black EditionNestor Miranda Collection Grand ReserveSan Cristobal EleganciaLa Aroma de Cuba Mi AmorTatuaje Black Label

Cigar Aficionado’s Hall of Fame

CUSTOMER'S REVIEWS

OVERALL

4.66

368 reviews

How reviewers describe My Father The Judge

sweet

strong

smooth

good flavor

full bodied

favorite

good construction

good price

bad burn

fantastic

natural

floral

complex

mineral

full of flavor

easy

creamy

smooth flavor

Rated 4.38by 3,757 Aficionados

Select a cigar to leave a review!

John A.05/28/2026About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A beautiful cigar with a great origin story. One of, if not, the highest Cigar Aficionado scores I’ve ever seen at 98. Solid smoke with a great flavor, makes a great gift too at the price point. As far as value, this is one of the best cigars you can grab.

Muhammad Essop L.05/08/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Best cigar ever

Tyler L.04/22/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Outstanding cigar! Smoothe but powerful notes of spice and cedar.

Trenvick C.04/16/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Cigar of the year for a reason

simon a.04/06/2026About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Very underrated vitola

Larry S.02/21/2026About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar and will buy more !! Larry S.

Micheal Y.02/13/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

All around perfection with this cigar. A favorite for sure.

David C.02/03/2026About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Excellent cigar. I had not bothered with this cigar from MF believe me the draw taste, burn was as good as it gets.

Josh K.02/02/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Not my favorite, but a fine cigar. Draw is a tad tight to release the full potential. I'm only 3 in so far, but they have all been consistent in draw and burn. I would buy again, but with the hope of a better box, or possibly a longer size, which I had better results with from before could solve the issue

Dugué J.01/31/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

2 words: Box Worthy!

Dean O.01/17/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Definitely lives up to the hype

Juan B.01/13/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

My Father Cigars dismissed opposing counsel's case and the Judge dropped the gavel hard on this one. Wow! Phenomenal from the unwrapping to the end. I found it full-bodied, sweet como una colada con espumita. Yum. Also, smooth and flavorful. Easy draw. I've ordered more from Neptune.

ABDU A.01/03/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

excellent cigar

simon a.01/01/2026About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Another hit by my father

James C.12/18/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Firm construction, easy open draw, mostly even burn with only a couple of minor touchups needed. Full bodied and very toothy with tons of thick, rich and creamy blue-gray smoke and flavors of woodsy cedar, spicy black pepper and strong black coffee bittersweetness. An excellent cigar!

Glen W.12/13/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

I am happy I tried this cigar. I really like this vitola of this blend. Worth a try.

Brandt W.12/11/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A very nice cigar..not over the top but not to mild either. Nicely done

Angel G.11/30/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

A medium to full-bodied smoke with deep notes of wood, leather, and spice.

Craig B.11/23/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

The taste was not good. I’m surprised. Draw was a bit tight. Burn was ok.

Ceanothus G.11/21/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Nice stick

Thomas H.11/13/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar. Perfect construction, draw and burn. Earth and toasted woody notes with a really enjoyable sweet cream element. Highly recommend.

Eran A.11/07/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Good draw, trying to figure out the hype. It's alright, maybe it's my fault for expecting way more. Overall it's just good.

Hubert S.10/28/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great smoke!

Daniel F.10/28/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Superb cigar from My Father in my favorite vitola.

Daniel F.10/27/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Superb cigar from the Garcia family.

Patrick H.10/06/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

This is a great go to smoke

Matthew A.10/01/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Good cigar

Matthew A.10/01/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great draw, well constructed, and a good value

MARK W.09/29/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I love the judge line and this is a perfect quick smoke

ross t.09/27/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Simply the best!

Simon M.09/10/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Truly blown away by this one, complex yet smooth flavor, interesting development throughout, spot on performance, quite the difference from the Toro which I have to say disappointed me, I'm glad I tried this, this is for the humidor

Robert L.08/28/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar!! Fantastic flavor!

Jose E.08/28/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar from Pepin

Giuliano M.08/19/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar

Jacob A.07/26/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Sophisticated flavor, tobacco, spice, and an herbal finish. Herbal notes and spiciness more pronounced 1/3 of the way through, then caramel undertones 1/2 way through.

Jimmy S.07/18/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Same draw throughout

AVINASH G.07/11/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great taste and aroma. Slight issue with the draw and burn in the final third which corrected itself. Wrapper torn slightly when removing last band.

Youssef Z.07/01/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Good stuff

Dean Z.07/01/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Definitely one of the best smokes out there, always have a few in the humidor

Christopher C.06/29/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Yes

Mehmet K.06/28/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

It was right humidity but still burning wasn’t good

Nala W.06/27/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar full of flavor!

Jacob K.06/21/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great. Not much to be said that others haven't. If your on the fence about it, get it. Worth the $14

peter a.06/18/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great smoke

Ali N.06/15/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Smooth

Jose A.06/15/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Delicious !!

Sam Y.06/11/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Great cigar. Deep, rich, satisfying flavors.

Levent Ö.06/04/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

98 points? Cigar of the 2024? Really? I always love the construction and draw of MF cigars but this doesn't taste really different than their Tatuaje Capa Especial Bon Chasseur blend. Same spiciness and pepper which is normal with Ecuadorian Sumatra-Seed. I don't get any wood or leather with this, only spice. Highly overrated.

Angus P.06/03/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Decent cigar with typical my father spice. Still unsure why it got the no. one spot on CA.

SHU MING J.05/30/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Great rich flavor cigar.

Lorenzo R.05/26/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Truly amazing.! In my top 5 favorite..????

shaun c.05/25/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

????

Daniel H.05/20/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I really wanted to like this cigar. It did have a nice draw and a good burn but the cigar was harsh and the flavors just weren't there. Maybe I'll revisit again someday.

Anthony M.05/09/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Awesome smoke, great for a Friday treat

Alex G.04/27/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

An absolute chocolate bomb.

Michael C.04/25/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

full-body, full-flavor with notes of cocoa and chocolate. excellent draw and construction.

Alex S.04/24/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I smoked one of these about a year ago when CA gave it a 95. It was very good but I was underwhelmed. Since CA made it No. 1, I have smoked 5 and they have all been fantastic!

Jose A.04/07/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great draw, burn and taste. I see why it got number 1.

Junior S.03/23/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Cigar of the year...sure sure, :eye roll: here..

Hakan D.03/16/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Fantastic cigar

Luz H.03/14/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A smoke for fans of medium to full bodied cigars, with a reddish-brown Sumatra seed wrapper grown in Ecuador that gives this stick a rich flavor of earth and spice. There is white pepper and cinnamon that comes not just from this wrapper, but also from the double binder Corojo and Criollo leaves. I rarely go for the thick ring gauges such as this one but in this case, it works. The Jalapa and Esteli fillers in the blend balance each other, one providing a creamy and smooth flavor and the other a bolder, more leathery and spicy flavor. This is a well balanced smoke that will satisfy your craving. Regardless of whether you consider it to be worthy of the Best Cigar of the Year award or not, I encourage you to forget the accolades and just enjoy this cigar for what it is: a damn good cigar!

Joseph M.03/12/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

There are a mind-bending amount of flavors in this cigar. It may not be Cigar of the Year worthy for everybody, but it’s definitely something everybody should try once at the very least.

Darryl F.03/09/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Excellent full bodied stick with notes of leather and spice.

Danny C.03/06/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Solid cigar but COTY and the score it received seems way beyond a stretch. Still worth trying for certain though!

Nikolla I.02/27/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Nothing special to be fair but worth the money, i dont know how they rank this cigar of the year

Ben J.01/29/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

One of the rare Sumatra seed wrappered cigars I truly loved. Amazing coffee and leather top notes with some wood and earth underneath. I had to open a tight draw, only complaint.

Deshbir B.01/25/2025About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A splendid smoke. Deserved cigar of the year - in fact the entire my father judge line has consistently been the best range of non Cuban cigars I have smoked in the recent years. A sublime yet full flavoured smoke and to think it costs just about $ 12 or so a stick is quite incredible. From a region where inconsistency is commonplace not sure how my father delivers such amazing long fillers and quality wrappers so consistently in such a well priced smoke - well done and congratulations to them

Glenjamin Benny G.01/21/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Holy flavor bomb that gives off a great aroma! Smoke one, you be the judge

Robert M.01/20/2025About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

A winner by the My Father factory. I do prefer the le bijou over this one but this is still an excellent medium to full-bodied cigar.

Martyn W.01/18/2025About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

The Judge is an impressive cigar from start to finish. It has a beautiful box-pressed shape and a dark, oily wrapper that screams quality. The draw is spot-on, and the burn is slow and even, producing thick clouds of smoke. Flavor-wise, it’s a powerhouse—earthy and woody with notes of leather, dark chocolate, and a hint of spice that lingers nicely. The aroma is rich and inviting, adding to the experience. If you’re into full-bodied cigars with lots of complexity, this one’s a must-try.

Alex G.12/29/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Excellent cigar. Can be a little overpowering, but it brings tons of flavor. A perfect burn and construction every time.

Brandt W.12/26/2024About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A lovely cigar

Christian A.12/20/2024About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I've smoked several of these and they are full of wood, earth, coffee with a rich finish of nougat and wood notes.

samer i.12/19/2024About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Always a great cigar from a great company

Spencer S.12/05/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I've had this cigar a few times and my opinions have changed over that period of time. This is very forward in its taste and complexity however, I have yearned for more interesting tasting cigars but would accept this if offered! Great cigar if you've never had it!

Vic V.11/10/2024About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Great cigar

Simon M.10/30/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I think my expectations were perhaps too high and I ended up being a tad disappointed by the Judge... Few things to say, I cannot in any way understand why this is considered full bodied cigar, in comparison with La Opulencia, Le Bijou and the Original this is medium at best. Secondly the flavor profile is dull. There is a hint of spice, hint of oily earthiness at the beginning but the longer you smoke it, the more it tastes like food that is desperately wanting for seasoning. Aroma also not a bit bland.. From a construction point of view this is a masterpiece, the stick is firm, draw was a little stiff at the beginning but after an inch or so it started going well and burn was even throughout. I will try again but this might just not be one for me.

Timothy E.09/27/2024About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Very good! My Father rarely misses. Very good flavor profile just slightly heavy on the draw. Most MF’s vary from cigar to cigar with the draw even from the same box. Still very good

Octavio O.08/08/2024About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Full body great aroma and full flavors

Chris S.07/22/2024About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Solid cigar. Not my preferred tasting notes, but if you like chocolate, cedar, hazelnut, and coffee, this is right up your alley. If that was my preference it would check all of the boxes.

Christopher C.07/15/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

It's called the judge for a reason

Chris P.06/14/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Excellent full body cigar. would definitely order again.

Brian B.05/14/2024About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Probably the best MF imo

Glenn C.05/11/2024About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Very nice!

Robert B.04/28/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Awesome cigar one of my favorites right now.

Brad S.04/24/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Loaded with flavor, burned quite uneven. Overall good, will definitely give it another try

Martin F.03/25/2024About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Just smoked this cigar for the first time. Draw was good and general construction was good outside of some burn line issues that required touch up. The flavor profile was mainly a dry cocoa power (chocolate ) taste, with some pepper on the front half. Second half kept the dry cocao taste and had some woodiness. Overall a good but not great cigar.

Brian B.03/04/2024About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Pretty solid. Not my favorite, but worth a try

Val B.01/08/2024About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Excellent cigar! Some pepper at first, then earthy, chocolate, coffee, sweet and creamy. A perfect draw and burn.

Brad D.01/04/2024About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great smoke all around , even burn, The 2nd was my flavour part

Paul R.12/22/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My father always delivers and the judge is no different. Bit of a bad burn but I also didn't let it rest. Too excited to try it

Gerrad B.12/21/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Oh boy I really enjoyed this smoke start to finish!!!

12/13/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

For me these are wonderful to smoke. They are however at the top of my price range so I cherish the times I light one up with a great whiskey. Perfect

Adam G.12/12/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

one of my favorite smokes. the size and shape of these make it such a great smoke, with a smooth draw and a huge flavor.

Subrata B.12/11/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Good

Ben W.12/07/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great smoke, stays lit. Great box

John S.11/28/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Very good

Pejman A.11/25/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

One of my favorites!

Eric P.11/16/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A nice, rich smoke with a flawless draw and burn.

nicholas l.11/07/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I put 5 stars across the board and didn’t even have to think about it. The draw is very very light. It burned straight as an arrow the whole way through. It didn’t have an incredibly sophisticated taste to me, but it was delicious nonetheless.

Bill M.11/05/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Absolutely superb cigar, packed full of flavour, great burn, great construction! One of my favourites. Preferably in a bigger vitola though

David P.10/28/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Still my favourite cigar

William H.10/10/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar. Strong chocolate notes really well balanced with some of the softer notes in the cigar. Construction was great only needed one minor touch up. The order was also packaged great shipped super quick and all the cigars in the order were in perfect condition.

peter a.10/07/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

The best my father

brandon b.09/30/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

????

Ivon09/29/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Earth, leather, espresso, bitter cocoa, same base flavor profile as the other sizes, but torcedor strength and boldness. Not 4 novices, but well worth the challenge.

Alex G.09/27/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Again a huge Judge fan! Like the shorter one, only longer! Really happy with the My Father brand, so good, any easy go to cigar, never disappoints!

Alex G.09/27/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

An all time favorite! The Judge, is a smokers cigar, not only in looks, but in flavor!

Matt M.09/25/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Absolutely fantastic. One of my all time favorites. Chocolate and some sweetness, but balance as well. Highly recommend.

Michael H.09/13/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Not for me

Matt M.09/12/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

One of my favorites

Edward W.08/17/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Never disappointed with my father a great smoke

Steven T.08/16/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A good bold stick

Dennis H.08/07/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

One of my favorites! Great full flavor without being a complete smack in the face.

Bill M.08/07/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This has become one of my favourite cigars! Pure flavour from start to finish! Absolutely delicious, no pepper tasted though, even on the retro! Burn was slightly off but apart from that it was superb!!! I will definitely be ordering more!!!

Nelson E.07/31/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

It was okay

John K.07/20/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Lots of smoke good draw nice taste in my top 5 you be the Judge

Eric Z.07/11/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

It was like smoking a mild dark chocolate bar. Very nice

Christopher S.06/29/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A good full bodied cigar that is heavy on the spice. Too spicy for me. Construction looked good but the burn was off. Overpriced for me.

Dennis H.06/22/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A great full bodied cigar. Highly recommended it you like strong cigars.

Kyle C.06/04/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

A favorite of mine. You will not be disappointed with this. Smooth and tasty.

Alexander H.06/01/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar, high quality. Because of the ring gauge, it takes some work to light with matches. Easy draw, Burns pretty even.

Craig B.05/30/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Not as expected. It had a pretty hard draw even after 3-4 piercings. Burn wasn’t greatest but not terrible either. RH was 70 so this might have been better at 62-65%

Glenn C.05/30/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

One of the greats!!

Josh C.05/30/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Quickly becoming one of my personal favorites.

T. B.05/12/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Decided to change up from my usual 60 ring gauge and try a different size. Just as good.

Steven D.05/08/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Literally one of my favourite cigars of all time. Truly amazing.

Cary S. K.05/07/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

A great maduro from MF

Onca05/05/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A must try .. A must have. Another great one by MF cigars

Arnold E.05/02/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Very smooth, smoking cigar

Hugo N.04/20/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Awesome smoke burn very even and smoothly

Ryan F.04/20/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

One of my top 5

Dan N.04/12/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Bought another 5 immediately after smoking. Another gem from My Father.

Roland S.04/09/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

good smoke time

Scott C.04/04/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar

Bob P.04/03/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Smooth mild and tasty.

Frank V.04/03/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar

eduardo d.03/31/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Not bad

Marcin P.03/22/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Can't go wrong with My Father, always good buy.

Kyle G.03/17/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Ordered 2... highly satisfied and impressed with the blend and how it pairs... ordering more soon

John Gold03/17/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Super Duper … loved this cigar

Frank V.03/06/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Okay cigar. Thought it would be better

Angel A.03/05/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Nice burn taste is a little on the peppery side. Nice draw.

Frank L.03/04/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

9 hole cigar

Frank L.03/04/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

nice break

Eric V.03/02/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Another great cigar by My Father

Eric V.03/02/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

This is my new favorite cigar. The Judge

Ron N.02/28/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

i never by full boxes. with cigar I did !!

Max V.02/27/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

GREAT BURN

charles m.01/30/2023About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This cigar was good from when i lit it to the end. The draw and burn was great. Nice strong cigar and definitely box worthy for me

Mario B.01/17/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

It does not disappoint excellent

Philip B.01/02/2023About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

A great smoke and a well constructed

Stanley B.01/01/2023About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Don Pepin Garcia out does himself with this one. Will always be in my humidor. A truly unique smoke.

Darryl F.12/20/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Excellent stick - very smooth and complex profile.

Denis S.12/15/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

10/10 upon my fav smokes ever.

Michael S.12/14/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Very good cigar.

Hugo N.12/14/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

One of my all time favorite it's a perfect smoke

Mark L.12/12/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My favorite My father. Peppery, chocolatey and woody. Great smoke!

Randy G.12/06/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

In a class by itself this Smoke. Absolute beast.

Keith L.11/24/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great stick. Nice pepper with a fairly complex taste throughout. A little more expensive than my usual smoke, but well worth it. I'll smoke this one again.

Shane R.11/23/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Can’t get enough of these- my “go to” cigar of choice. You better have a bit to smoke one though lol

Mario T.11/18/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Very nice mild smoke. Smooth flavor and well constructed.

EMMANUEL R.11/15/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Bon cigare.

Jim L.10/26/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Guys night on Tuesdays I brought them and passed them out and everyone really enjoyed them

Dustin R.10/23/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Swell

Elliott W.10/04/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

good cigar

Dustin R.10/04/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Amazing

victor e.10/03/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

a great cigar with ample complexity great construction great smoke output and great flavors

Stanley C.09/22/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

If you are a coffee drinker this is perfect stick, full of chocolate and cocoa notes

Courtney C.09/12/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

New vitola, to me, still excellent smoke.

Courtney C.09/12/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Flavor bomb!!!

Nathan H.09/12/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

My top 5 smoke!

Robert D.09/11/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Much less imposing than I had imagined. Rich chocolate notes up front give way to a nice floral character with an underlying spice. Smoke is rich and voluminous with every pull. Perfect construction all around. Highly recommended for full body pufferators!!!

Chris T.09/06/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Good cigar when I want a slower burner last me about 1.5 hours

Ross H.08/24/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My first time smoking this cigar, what a treat! I purged it about halfway through and it really went to a higher level. Great

SHU MING J.08/24/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great rich flavor cigar.

Vito G.08/23/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Full flavored but smooth. No peppery bite

David P.08/19/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

My first full strength, loved it

Frank A.08/08/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Excellent cigar. Good flavor, flawless burn, and very aromatic.

SHU MING J.07/28/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Excellent smooth cigar.

Luc L.07/11/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

very good smoke

Cindy B.07/04/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Extremely great tasting stick.

Cody V.06/22/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Medium/Full-bodied- Coco, gingersnap, pepper, cream, almond, leather, coffee. Burn was a bit off. However, this is a go to cigar for me which i try and smoke once every couple months. 8.8 out of 10.

EMMANUEL R.06/20/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Bon cigare.

Jeremy H.06/19/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

This plump smoke was my Fathers Day treat to myself and I'm not at all disappointed. Great draw and burn especially for a 60 gauge. Wood, earth, leather, pepper, dark chocolate, they are all represented. Even the summer breezes couldn't stop this one. Excellent stick all around.

Tom R.06/15/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Well constructed, nice burn. Flavour was a mixed bag, but as the cigar progressed it improved especially in the final third.

Francisco T.06/13/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

it was ok

James L.06/07/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar for the money!

Chip S.05/23/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

My personal favorite from MF. Just a home run from start to finish.

Adam G.05/02/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

So disappointing

Adam G.05/02/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Lacking in the flavor department.

Will H.04/04/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Full flavor, great cigar

Gary R.03/30/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I rate My Fathers Judge toro ,my best top 3 all time Cigars ,and this box didn’t dissapoint ,thankyou Neptune Cigars for great service!!!!

Tamara L.03/18/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Theodore Z.03/07/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

This full-bodied gem requires some time to fully enjoy and appreciate. It is slow even burning, packed with slightly sweet aroma and flavors of earth and leather that dominate gentle overtones of dark chocolate and roasted nuts! If you are desiring, or if you are searching for, a smooth, hardy, full-bodied smoke with no bite or peppery aftermath, and delivers gentle notes that are slightly sweet without hindering the pleasures of full-bodied cigars, and where each puff yields generous amounts of smoke that do not irritate the eyes, then this is it! You have found it! Enjoy! The last third is a full-bodied experience that you will not forget, and will keep you coming back for more! Thank you NEPTUNE for offering us such wide varieties of cigars.

Steven H.02/26/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

I'm a big fan of My Father cigars (although of late the thinner ring gauges have been plagued with construction issues), but I didn't enjoy the first half of this cigar which I found to be unbalanced and confused. I smoked two of them to make sure and the flavour profile was just too intense and not well integrated enough

T. B.02/25/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Was my first 60 gage and definitely not going to be my last. Great smoke and appearance.

Waqas Y.02/17/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My father cigars never disappoint, first time trying the judge and what can i say an amazing smoke.

Gerardo C.02/12/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Excellent smooth cigar

Marcus H.02/08/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

One of my absolute favorites by my father

Mori D.02/07/2022About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Excellent cigar. Going to buy more.

Francis L.02/05/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Well worth the price tag. Favourite My Father. Powerhouse

T. B.01/31/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar.

su chen W.01/22/2022About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

nice

Theodore Z.01/12/2022About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

One of the best cigars I've ever experienced in my 20+ years. If you’re looking for a full-bodied cigar, the MF The Judge offers one of the best experiences that you’ll find.

Val B.12/29/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Excellent cigar! Pepper at first, then earthy, chocolate, coffee, sweet and creamy. A perfect draw and burn.

Philippe B.12/27/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Sure this is not a beginner cigar, but it's worth trying it.

Chris W.12/16/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

One of the best 60 gage smokes I ever smoked

Chris W.12/16/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I really adore my father. All their stogies are awesome

Evan G.12/15/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

great cigar all around

Alberto L.12/14/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great smoke. Second favorite to La Opulencia

pete a.12/13/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Good Day All, This item is amazing and you guys provided excellent customer service. Thanks again

Glen W.12/12/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Solid cigar

W.Eight N.12/11/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

One of my go-to cigar

Dan R.12/06/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This smooth tasting cigar was a pleasure to smoke, I did have to run my perfect draw tool up the center a couple times throughout the duration as it was a little difficult to draw. I was hoping for a little more flavor, but it didn't disappoint, looking forward to the next one.

Vinny D.11/26/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Amazing stick top 3! Great look, great draw, great burn. And flavor is full an awesome. 3/4 strength. Hints of cocoa, caramel, baking spice, sweat smooth vanilla, wood, & leather

W.Eight N.11/26/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I love it but it's too much big gauge

Douglas S.11/17/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

I think this cigar is overrated. So many better smokes at this price.

Karina N.11/09/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

One of the best from the brand

Richard P.10/31/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My Father Cigars has upped their game again. Very well balanced and slow burning, certainly glad I grabbed a box of these. Fantastic!

emade E.10/06/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Bon cigare

Frank B.09/23/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

As usual with My Father the construction was perfect. Razor sharp burn, great draw, ample smoke. The flavors weren’t really in my wheelhouse however.

Carlos D.09/22/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I just love this cigar. Nice taste draw is great

Tom M.09/20/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar

Todd N.09/06/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A great cigar. Wholeheartedly this smoke to any and every one.

aaron09/01/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Never had a bad My Father..

Philip B.08/20/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

nice and slow burn, lovely taste

tim08/19/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Can't go wrong with this smoke good flavors through out.

Victor A.07/26/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Nice one

Kirt S.07/15/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Stronger then I used to but very enjoyable and will order more.

Durane John07/09/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great smoke and texture

Christopher G.06/10/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Very powerful smoke, but very flavorful. Abundance of chocolate and pepper spice. Draw and burn were nearly perfect. This is a nice stick and worth having on a periodic basis.

Kevin T.06/07/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

One of my all time favorites out of the my father line up.

Fred P.06/07/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Never have I smoked a My Father and not enjoyed it

J J.05/17/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Good flavors from this one. Dark but not overly sweet. Full body I think it’s in my top 5 from my father

VIncent N.05/12/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Another great recommendation. A great change of mind pace

Jim E.05/07/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Great cigar for the price point, My father brand is always a good choice and this one did not let me down

Russell J.05/06/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Fantastic all around cigar. Woodsy, white pepper, even a little vanilla and almost. Great construction, fantastic draw and burn. Really can't go wrong with this cigar in this size.

Randall F.04/05/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Perfect burn. Earthy taste dominates

Eric P.04/04/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A full-bodied flavor-bomb. Take your time and savor this one.

Subrata B.04/02/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Good

Joseph S.03/23/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

This is a Top Notch Cigar at a outstanding price.

Cefi E.03/14/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Perfection rolled into a Gorgeous Cigar. Veinless habano rosado wrapper that is immaculate. Solid, you can feel the expertise rolled on this seamless Cigar. Draw is Amazing, the standard for everyone to follow. Was so excited to smoke this beauty that I did not even do a cold draw. Once lit, a mouthful of spicy smoke greets you. Burn was razor sharp, with ash holding for 2 inches under windy conditions. After a 1st/3rd dominated by spice, there a smooth transition giving way to tasty tobacco with a mild earthy walnut flavor. Mild flavored but full strength without being overpowering, just perfect. Smoke volume is also Perfect, one puff gives you a mouthful of smoth earthy goodness. Last 3rd gets a bit darker, with tobacco balanced with a little spice. Aged a week short of 4 months. I truly enjoyed this Cigar.

Fred S.03/09/2021About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My new favorite, for sure. Although not in everyone's humidor, they should be. One of the most even burning, best tasting cigars I've had the pleasure to enjoy!

Anthony M.03/09/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Dark and choco heavy

Joseph K.02/28/2021About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Another great my father stick!

Doug S.02/24/2021About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

One of my favorites; certainly in my top 5! Try it and you'll end up buying a box!

charles S.12/30/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

The overall perfect cigar

Hamad A.12/20/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great smoke! this cigar is one of the finest

Hamad A.12/20/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great Smoke! this cigar is one of the finest of my father

Raul/ Erica .12/17/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

The judge it is and should be judge as box worthy

BRUCE C.12/16/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

You can't go wrong with the Judge - Awesome smoke!

Junior S.12/16/2020About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

You can't go wrong with My Father. First time smoking the The Judge in corona. Nice and spicy.

Andrew T.12/14/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

This right here is my favorite cigar. This brand never disappoints.

Bradley C.12/14/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Good all around cigar.

samer i.12/01/2020About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Spice and Leather

Jake K.11/09/2020About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

My Father excellent as usual.

Robert P.10/21/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

The judge was hard to find. I had to go in-person to the store and I was lucky enough to grab a couple. This cigar did not let me down.

Jaime V.09/02/2020About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

One of my favorite cigars from Don Pepín.

Todd G.08/22/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Very smooth cigar. I would highly recommend this.

James S.08/20/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

top notch cigar. worth the price. you wont be disappointed

Martin T.08/11/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar. Smooth tasting.

Jake H.07/29/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Very solid cigar, smooth with lots of flavor.

Thayer M.07/20/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

One of my all time favorites

wade o.07/15/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

always smoke the brand.first time for this one.but it should be just as good..

carmine d.07/02/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar, great taste not my first not my last

Nick D.06/23/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Deep and full flavors. Loved it

Raul/ Erica .06/16/2020About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

you want to get this nice and rich flavored cigar.. do recommend

Eric B.06/13/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

This little powerhouse has become a favorite and a definite goto. I keep them stocked in my collection at all times. The flavor profile is just fantastic. One simply cannot go wrong here. I have found it a bit strong for my friends and who prefer medium to mild sticks. But for me it’s just right. Like always I bought a few to see if I’d like them. After the very first one I was hooked and ordered my first box shortly thereafter. Give them a try. I doubt you’ll be disappointed.

Alan W.05/21/2020About: My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

Yes, finally The Judge in a smaller ring gauge! The other two sizes I've tried were good but bigger than I like.

Theron L.05/10/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Just a banger for me, super strong that Pepin is known for. A little asskicker from the start: leather,pepper, choc, barnyard, musty, several graham cracker puffs as well

Donny A.05/04/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This is a must purchase. I love this stick from My Father.

Chuck V.04/22/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This one was okay. I was actually not really impressed. I like a few of the other My Father blends way more than this one.

Jack H.04/20/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

This is one of my favorite cigars!

Jason G.04/15/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Looks impressive. I was expecting more. I had the Punch Diablo Brute a few days before so I was ready for The Judge to be similar but in comparison it fell flat in flavor

Peter V.04/09/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

well rounded smoke

Kervin M.04/08/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar but a bit overpriced

Gabriel F.03/06/2020About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Unlike my real father, My Father never disappoints.

Garrett M.03/06/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Full of flavor.

Daniel L.02/02/2020About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Awesome stogies

George P.12/27/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

All Rise... My Father Cigars has introduced The Judge. This great Nicaraguan cigar has an Ecuadorian Sumatra Oscuro wrapper, a Nicaraguan Corojo binder, and Nicaraguan filler. This combination gives the cigar a nice medium to medium-full body and powerful taste. At first light, you are introduced to a nice medium tobacco flavor. Hints of pepper are introduced along with some hints of oak and cedar. The pepper is not an overwhelming amount, just enough to entice the palate. At halfway through the cigar, a nice hint of spice is introduced. Again, not overwhelming. It compliments the flavors that you are enjoying from the first part of the cigar. As we approach the end of the cigar, the spice diminishes a little. You will still taste it, but not as much as before. All the other flavors are still there, while the strength does pick up a little. This is a great cigar for those who enjoy a good medium to medium-full body smoke. Try it. I am sure you will like it!

Curtis C.11/14/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar.

Nadeem Wali11/14/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

pepper bomb as usual from my father!

steve k.11/13/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Started slow but consistent

Justin B.11/10/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

decent

Rudy D.11/03/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

The best of MF by far!!!

vincent b.10/23/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Man this is one of my favorite smokes!!!

Bryan M.10/22/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Amazing stick from beginning to end.

Gregory G.10/17/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A great cigar

rudy m.09/17/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Good value for the money. Great smoke

gemal r.08/26/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

excellent cigar, nice smoke and draw

gemal r.08/26/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

excellent cigar, nice smoke and draw

Christine D.08/25/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Really enjoyed this cigar

08/05/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Like th 1922 better

jerry b.07/17/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Really enjoyed this one. Seemed to burn better with long draws on it. Didn’t think I would like a full bodied cigar, but this surprised me

Geomaly M.07/13/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Nice and full tasting cigar

BADR S.07/05/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Nice cigar

Sunil S.07/03/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Large cigar, great looking. Cant wait to smoke!

Michael W.06/26/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Reminiscent of the MY Father of old. Red pepper, espesso bean, chocolate, and tangy dark fruit make this one of my favorites by MF.

Mori D.06/20/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Strong flavors from the start. This cigar was very good but slightly harsh at times. I’m going to let the next one rest a few months.

Subrata B.06/08/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar.

Jesus I.05/29/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Kevin O.05/13/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Awesome

Elvin D.04/16/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

First and second third were as anyone would expect from this cigar. The final third had severe burn issues which threw off the flavor of the cigar. I also could not keep it lit.

Felix G.04/13/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Very tight cigar but great nonetheless. Hints of cocoa, leather and nuts bring this great cigar together.

Antonio Q.04/09/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great cigar.

Alejandro C.04/01/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Nice!

Corey G.03/25/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great smoke...

mohammed z.03/05/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My father always has great surprising and unique flavors and i love that. The flavors are complex and intriguing.

Samuel A.02/26/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

The judge is perfect for great moment. perfect draw, burn. The ash fits perfecly and during a long time.

Larry J.02/20/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

really love this cigar

Rudy D.01/28/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

A very elegant and constant smoke

Thomas K.01/21/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Big cedar notes with dark chocolate and nut. Worth it to get a box.

william f.01/16/2019About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

The foot offers a peppery lead aroma, a bit of earth, chocolate and a sharp note of cold coffee. The Judge puts out a good amount of smoke shortly after being lit

Ibrahim M.01/14/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Who’s judging

Christian M.01/13/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Medium to full body, enjoyable experience...

Andrew T.01/07/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

By far my favorite cigar company on the market. This has to be my favorite cigar to date. All 5 phases you want in a cigar are in the Nicaraguan beauty

Carlos Y.01/04/2019About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great! Excellent! No more comments! One of my favorites.

Arturo S.12/03/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

top

Carlos Y.12/03/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Really a great cigar!!!!

Michael R.11/30/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Perfect Little Cigar!

Lee H.11/20/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This is a fantastic smoke. My Father never disappoints and the The Judge is no exception. A great maduro with a bit of a kick at the end. I make sure to keep at least one in my humidor at all times

Robert I.11/17/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I had one of these the other night after a great meal and it topped off the night. This one is a strong full-bodied cigar just what the doctor ordered I will be by anymore . Leslie gore never had to be related in burn even all the way through with a big white plume of smoke .

tim11/16/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A excellent cigar.

Anthony H.11/05/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Fantastic smoke!

Josue M.10/20/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Cocoa explosion.

Andrew H.10/10/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Tough call between the Judge and La Opulencia. I love them both. If you like Maduro’s try these

Ozzie H.10/06/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Excellent

David W.09/22/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

A staple in the humi. Let it age

brady h.08/28/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Read great reviews about this cigar, aging for a few before trying

Jason S.08/20/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Loved this cigar!!!

Alan J.08/13/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Lots of smoke

Kevin G.08/02/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Love My Father. The Judge is my fav. Well constructed, great flavor, complete satisfaction.

Kevin G.08/02/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

My Father cigars are not for the weak taste buds. Stout throughout with a stronger finish. Love the Judge

Mark J.08/01/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Never disappointing. One of my favorites.

Doug C.07/31/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Leather, hot cinnamon, anise, earth, dark chocolate, creamy flavors.

Daniel C.07/29/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

This cigar is amazing. Best cigar I have tried in a long time. I recently purchased a box of these and the 6x56 Toro. My advice is to get this one; for some reason the 60 ring is better by far.

Chris H.07/19/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

well crafted and complex cigar

IntertradeBKK W.07/04/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great Cigar.

cesar n.06/28/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Nice cigar with a good draw

James G.06/12/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

An excellent smoke.

Corey D.05/31/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

One of my favorites

Danny S.05/30/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

IMHO it's a little over hyped and over priced

Adam G.05/17/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Excellent smoke with a cold one.

Glenn B.05/07/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Nice cigar. Needed a few months in the humi.

Vincent B.05/07/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

nice cigar I believe you get what you pay for worth every penny.

Eric S.04/17/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I’m not one to typically smoke a cigar with this large of a ring guage but with all of the accolades I gave it a try. It was a really nice smoke in all areas though wasn’t as complex as I thought it might be. If you like My Father Cigars it’s one yuh should definitely try

Bob G.04/06/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I waited a long time for these to be back in stock and it was well worth it. Full strength but smooth at the same time. Draw was excellent. Ill be ordering more!

Rojelio V.03/14/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My favorite MF stick

Alan C.02/26/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Loved the Le Bijou 1922 and loving this big boy too! lovely

Kevin Link02/24/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Very good new cigar from my father! Pretty bulky robusto has a little more strength than the original my father. Burn was awesome with very clean ash. Smoke billows of this stick!!

Daniel W.02/22/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Nice stick but not as good as the regular My Father line or Le Bijou

Jason M.01/14/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Creamy deliciousness! Tons of smoke, hazelnut, chocolate, dark chocolate, caramel, and a bit of leather to top it off. Wow oh wow, this is where its at!

Eduard N.01/06/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Enjoyed every puff.

Nicholas T.01/03/2018About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Excellent smoke. I'll definitely order this one again!

Pat01/02/2018About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

There's a reason Cigar Aficionado has this cigar in their Top 25 for 2017. Full bodied stick that delivers. Good draw and flavor.

Kyle W.11/28/2017About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

The best MF of the line currently. You can't go wrong with either size. Truly exceptional.

Tim F.11/11/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This is an okay cigar; one of my least favorite My Fathers. Very mild flavor, pretty good burn, excellent smoke production. However, you're better off with a different My Father.

Kyle W.11/09/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Exquisite. Absolutely box worthy. I can't believe how perfect this cigar was. Flawless performance and extraordinary flavor.

Hugh H.10/23/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

nice full bodied smoke

Andy c.09/15/2017About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

Great cigar!! Good draw and the burn never goes out. A little bit of spice with some sweetness. Not too strong.

Patrick C.08/24/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Well constructed cigar but nothing about the taste or aroma really grabbed my attention

Ben G.08/18/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

This cigar looked great, burned great and tasted great. It had the good quality one has come to expect from the My Father franchise.

Thomas O.08/11/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

The look of this stick is great. Its a very tight cigar but the draw is wonderful. Taste of spice but not overpowering throughout. I will buy again

MICHAEL C.08/09/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Great tsste to the nub.

Lionel H.08/09/2017About: My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

I only recently tried this but have developed quite an affection for this. The Judge is cigar with a good burn and a delicious taste. Pairs well for me with a glass of Cognac!

Allinton W.07/17/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

Practically perfect cigar, enjoyed every bit of it. Perfect burn, construction and great flavor.

Rene L.07/16/2017About: My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

I've been eager to smoke this one for a long, long time. After months of being asked for it by numerous customers, The Judge has finally arrived at Neptune, and I'm happy to say it lived up to the hype. If you're already a fan of My Father cigars, then you know a little bit of what to expect: a perfectly harmonious marriage of spice and cream, with a delectably sharp yet smooth aroma. Right from the start, notes of almond and pepper flooded my palate, while hints of leather and fig swirled around throughout. The solid box-pressed construction offered a strong ash and an even burn. No re-lights needed. I would classify this cigar as medium to full-bodied in strength, however, it is definitely full in flavor. Pair it with some nice scotch! Another terrific offering from My Father. BONUS: Also available in a cool 5 x 60 vitola for those who prefer fatter stogies.

My Father The Judge

My Father The Judge Corona Gorda 5"5/8 * 46

My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" * 60

My Father The Judge Toro 6" * 56

My Father Limited Edition Father's Day 8-Cigar Sampler with Accessories

Your Account

Quick Reorder

Edit Your Profile

Track an Order

Redeem Smoke Rings

Wish Lists

Cigar & Smoking

Cigar Tutorial

Cigar Storage

Humidor Care

Lighters 101

Cutter 101

Ashtrays 101

Customer Service

Testimonials

Shipping Policy

Contact Us

Fort Lauderdale Cigar SuperStore

Little Havana Cigar SuperStore

Pinecrest Cigar SuperStore

FAQ

Name:

Email:

Comments: